Derek Ellis

2.8K posts

Derek Ellis banner
Derek Ellis

Derek Ellis

@deellisd

Katılım Nisan 2011
162 Takip Edilen184 Takipçiler
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@EricDLombardi @GraphicMatt Whether it's jumping the hurdles to contact to the signalling system, or mounting the trains with the same kind of GPS units that the streetcars use.. it's more than just being restricted from accessing it. I mean, why can't the TTC publish data for their own subways?
English
0
0
1
91
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@EricDLombardi @GraphicMatt This is a red herring. The arrival times are estimates on data from the signalling system. Even if the TTC had access to it, I wouldn't count on them being able to publish it. There's no data for Line 5, Line 1, or in fact ANY urban rail system in Canada (minus the streetcars)
English
1
0
1
528
Eric Lombardi (EricForOLP.ca) 🇨🇦🚀
This is a bananas, buried in @GraphicMatt’s latest newsletter. Please keep in mind Finch Line 6 was awarded to a consortium partner (Mosaic) in a P3 (public private partnership) model. And they are limiting data access to the TTC on the location and arrival times for a major new LRT. This is one of those nonsense outcomes where the user/consumer is put last in consideration due to political jurisdictional haggling. @PrabSarkaria needs to get on the line with leaders at Metrolinx and Mosaic and demand they quit the nonsense excuse making, and pronto. A very silly outcome for transit users in Toronto, failed by the province’s inability to manage its partners.
Eric Lombardi (EricForOLP.ca) 🇨🇦🚀 tweet media
English
2
12
117
18.3K
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@JakeLandauTO It sounds very silly, but a surprising reality is that no rail system in Canada publishes real-time train positions *sourced from their signalling systems*. So forget Finch West, why can't the TTC publish the locations of their automatically controlled subway trains..?
English
2
1
5
371
Jake Landau (He/Him) 🇨🇦🇵🇸🇻🇪🇺🇦
Am I reading this right? The Finch streetcar doesn't have live vehicle data because the private consortium doesn't want people to actually see when their train will arrive?
Eric Lombardi (EricForOLP.ca) 🇨🇦🚀@EricDLombardi

This is a bananas, buried in @GraphicMatt’s latest newsletter. Please keep in mind Finch Line 6 was awarded to a consortium partner (Mosaic) in a P3 (public private partnership) model. And they are limiting data access to the TTC on the location and arrival times for a major new LRT. This is one of those nonsense outcomes where the user/consumer is put last in consideration due to political jurisdictional haggling. @PrabSarkaria needs to get on the line with leaders at Metrolinx and Mosaic and demand they quit the nonsense excuse making, and pronto. A very silly outcome for transit users in Toronto, failed by the province’s inability to manage its partners.

Toronto, Ontario 🇨🇦 English
5
36
231
11.5K
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@MrBBeard OC Transpo makes the raw data publicly available so you can at least build the dashboard yourself, like the folks at Better Transit Ottawa did. bettertransitottawa.ca
English
0
0
0
47
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@StephenWickens1 None of the issues that could be (tenuously) classified as "brake issues" in Ottawa have any effect on top speed. Ottawa's trains still regularly run up to 80km/h.
English
0
0
0
13
Stephen Wickens 🇺🇦 🇨🇦
Stephen Wickens 🇺🇦 🇨🇦@StephenWickens1·
If I had to put money down on why the trains are being driven so slowly, I'd bet it's a vehicle issue, or, more specifically, braking systems that don't work so well in winter weather. Finch West, like the Confederation Line in Ottawa, is running Alstom Citadis trains.
Stephen Wickens 🇺🇦 🇨🇦 tweet media
Stephen Wickens 🇺🇦 🇨🇦@StephenWickens1

There may be something wrong with the vehicles and tracks, too. TTC, Metrolinx and IO need to start thinking more about protecting the public than they do about saving powerful people from embarrassment. Secrecy invariably slows the process of learning the right lessons.

English
2
2
8
670
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@GoldeViolets @JakeLandauTO @MassJumbo Sure, Montreal has also had its share of projects that didn't go anywhere. But I'm only talking about things that are actively under construction and that is, again, far more than can be said of any other part of Montreal's regional network.
English
0
0
0
41
dennis de los santos
dennis de los santos@GoldeViolets·
@deellisd @JakeLandauTO @MassJumbo i mean look in 2010 we had transit city, in 205 we had smart track. go expansion obviously has way more money dedicated to it but both of those went up in flames so i have very little hope go expansion will deliver the true RER-inspired service they once aimed for
English
1
0
0
48
MaineJumbo🌲🦞
MaineJumbo🌲🦞@MassJumbo·
It’s crazy how Montreal has this amazing subway and now REM while it’s commuter rail is god awful even by US standards (mogged by Boston commuter rail for example) and they just don’t seem to care
English
26
31
909
57.6K
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@GoldeViolets @JakeLandauTO @MassJumbo The half-hourly service we have now is already better than every other Exo line, with no concrete plans for them to improve. The REM is great, but GO expansion is happening. Exo expansion isn't, and there isn't a second REM happening (anymore).
English
1
0
0
74
dennis de los santos
dennis de los santos@GoldeViolets·
@deellisd @JakeLandauTO @MassJumbo i dont really think we should count our eggs before they hatch. we'd be lucky to have 5-10 minute frequencies off-peak on an electrified lakeshore line by 2050, MTL has that from brossard to the west island NOW
English
1
0
1
79
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@JakeLandauTO @MassJumbo But that's more or less it for the foreseeable future. Compare that to what the future of GO looks like and it's a pretty stark difference in investment.
English
2
0
5
331
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@attainablehome4 @bmptrsn Montreal has a good transit network. Toronto has, by all means, a good transit network. But only Toronto has a slate of projects chugging along. You can believe it when you see it, but there's not much else to see in Montreal from here on out!
English
0
0
0
21
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@attainablehome4 @bmptrsn I don't mean that Montreal's transit system is bad, but the dismissal of Toronto's transit and growth as if it can't compete with Montreal's just doesn't make sense. We don't need to tear ourselves down to build ourselves up, least of all when there is *so much happening*.
English
1
0
0
22
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@attainablehome4 @bmptrsn But really my point is: you can't just cherry pick the REM and call Toronto deeply unserious when there's *this* much happening.
English
0
0
0
38
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@attainablehome4 @bmptrsn We've built the Vaughan subway extension, modernized Line 1's signaling, launched the UPX, massively expanded GO, also expanded bike lanes, etc. The grass is always greener. The lack of other ongoing projects in Montreal is really more worrying than anything in Toronto.
English
1
0
1
52
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@gorilla_fund @bmptrsn Yeah the REM is great, but it isn't the only rail project Montreal needs and yet it is one of the only ones actually happening. Anyway, this is really about Toronto where GO expansion will cover the entire region on top of a half dozen local projects.
English
0
0
2
89
800lb Gorilla Capital
800lb Gorilla Capital@gorilla_fund·
@deellisd @bmptrsn "the only" Dude the REM covers like half the island of Montreal and even some northern and southern suburbs. It's massive.
English
1
0
3
94
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@_NotA_Bot_ @bmptrsn Not really the "majority".. but even in spite of any cut backs it still remains the single largest transit expansion project in North America. Either way, it's more than can be said of the Montreal region's Exo.
English
1
0
3
134
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@mirgray I am curious how other cities report on infrastructure debt in their transit/transportation budgets. It is definitely odd that this is all falling under the umbrella of the transit operating budget, which itself has dedicated line items for bus/para + rail operations.
English
1
0
1
48
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@TonyPcar968 @JCHIANELLO His question narrowed the definition of "reliability" to only consider on-time performance, ignoring the investments being made to address the hundreds of unnecessarily cancelled trips that keep happening every week.
English
0
0
1
25
Tony_pcar968
Tony_pcar968@TonyPcar968·
@JCHIANELLO Riley pointed out the fact that the budget didn't have anything in it to actually improve bus reliability which is what riders are most frustrated with. His question about performance aligns with the lack of budget inclusion aligned with a reliability plan so very appropriate.
English
2
0
9
188
JOANNE CHIANELLO
JOANNE CHIANELLO@JCHIANELLO·
You can’t just make out-of-line comments and then be surprised when people take offence. I’d turn this around: by speaking disrespectfully and inappropriately at budget debate, Coun. Brockington has detracted from valid points regarding transit operations. #ottnews
Sean Devine@DevineSean

In my opinion, too much has been made about how my colleague @RiverWardRiley's questions were received, and not enough attention paid to the questions themselves. Personally, I do not think he owes GM Amilcar an apology. 1/ ottawa.ctvnews.ca/ottawa-council…

English
9
1
22
9.5K
Derek Ellis
Derek Ellis@deellisd·
@OttTransitRider @OC_Transpo There is a huge difference between speaking out, and suggesting (begging) that you be appointed as the general manager in an unhinged rant. This just adds to the mess of poorly formulated narratives about Ottawa's transit problems and signal boosting this does not help.
English
0
0
0
67