Fable

548 posts

Fable

Fable

@fablepond

Built a YouTube channel and community over the past year. Fighting my unfair demonetization every day, to my death.

Katılım Ocak 2023
143 Takip Edilen51 Takipçiler
Fable
Fable@fablepond·
Dear @TeamYoutube. It's been 44 days since my channel got demonetized for inauthentic content. I made a video explaining my situation and channel history. I want to show you all the proof you need, and I want to 100% comply with all policies but without a specific explanation behind my demonetization, I am clueless. Please @TeamYoutube review my channel: youtu.be/qzjFmM0Lmc4 @stevenyjsong @MovieTalkNOW1 @KreekCraft @YouTubeCreators #YouTubeDemonetized #Demonetized #CreatorSupport #YouTubeCreators #InauthenticContent #Roblox @YouTubeCreators @TeamYouTube @YouTube @YouTubeGaming
YouTube video
YouTube
English
22
11
31
2.1K
Fable retweetledi
Monumental
Monumental@real_Monumental·
Very well said. @YouTube your way of dealing with so many creators lately is absolutely unethical and UNACCEPTABLE. If a lack of human reviewers is the issue, then hire more! Having a platform where creators literally have to function in complete terror is not even remotely feasible long-term.
Nate Curtiss@natecurtiss_yt

An open letter to YouTube. We need to talk. Creators are waking up to terminated channels, wiped revenues, and years of work gone overnight. No warning. No explanation. No appeal that actually works. So on behalf of every creator who has ever put their life into this platform, here are our demands. 1. Tell us WHY. A termination email with zero context is not a policy. If you are going to end someone's livelihood, the least you can do is explain what they actually did wrong. 2. Fix the appeals process. Right now appealing a strike feels like shouting into a void. An automated rejection in 24 hours is not a review. We want real humans making real decisions. 3. Stop punishing whole channels for one video. One bad upload should not erase five years of content. Strike the video. Don't delete the creator. 4. Give us a warning before termination. A strike system exists for a reason. Use it. Creators should not be going from zero issues to fully terminated with no steps in between. 5. Be transparent about what is changing. Every few months the rules quietly shift and channels start disappearing. Tell us what changed. We are not mind readers. 6. Protect the creators who built this platform. YouTube would not exist without creators. The people losing their channels right now are not bad actors. Many of them are the reason people still open the app. We are not asking for special treatment. We are asking to be treated like partners, not liabilities. Reply if you agree.

English
9
16
47
2.3K
Fable retweetledi
Nate Curtiss
Nate Curtiss@natecurtiss_yt·
An open letter to YouTube. We need to talk. Creators are waking up to terminated channels, wiped revenues, and years of work gone overnight. No warning. No explanation. No appeal that actually works. So on behalf of every creator who has ever put their life into this platform, here are our demands. 1. Tell us WHY. A termination email with zero context is not a policy. If you are going to end someone's livelihood, the least you can do is explain what they actually did wrong. 2. Fix the appeals process. Right now appealing a strike feels like shouting into a void. An automated rejection in 24 hours is not a review. We want real humans making real decisions. 3. Stop punishing whole channels for one video. One bad upload should not erase five years of content. Strike the video. Don't delete the creator. 4. Give us a warning before termination. A strike system exists for a reason. Use it. Creators should not be going from zero issues to fully terminated with no steps in between. 5. Be transparent about what is changing. Every few months the rules quietly shift and channels start disappearing. Tell us what changed. We are not mind readers. 6. Protect the creators who built this platform. YouTube would not exist without creators. The people losing their channels right now are not bad actors. Many of them are the reason people still open the app. We are not asking for special treatment. We are asking to be treated like partners, not liabilities. Reply if you agree.
Nate Curtiss tweet media
English
188
193
558
28.2K
Fable retweetledi
UnderSparked
UnderSparked@MegaSparked·
We are going to sue YouTube But before we do, our lawyer is currently in the process of sending a letter to YouTube. Over 2 weeks ago our channel @UnderSparked" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@UnderSparked was falsely demonetized under the "inauthentic content" policy. Demonetized doesn't mean no ads though, all it means is YouTube will still run ads on the videos. But they pocket all the revenue, essentially stripping all the revenue from us. We don't claim to be the pinnacle of quality content standards, but the following things do cause us to scratch our heads in confusion 1. All of the bigger channels in the same niche as us are monetized with no issues 2. We literally voice act, edit, etc, all our own videos while 100s of AI storytelling channels are still monetized 3. YouTube is fine with running ads on the videos, pocketing all the revenue. We assume if YouTube had such a big problem with the content, why still serve it to your advertisers? 4. 100s of reaction channels still stay monetized Some examples of bigger monetized channels that are in the same niche as us are: rSlash: @rSlash" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@rSlash DarkFluff: @DarkFluff" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@DarkFluff Oz's Vault: youtube.com/channel/UCoJ1A… We support these channels, the reason we are providing these channels as examples is to showcase how it feels like we're being targeted. This has caused extreme distress for my team and I. Many of our livelihoods and families rely on this channel. Our community relies on the UnderSparked channel. Many people support the UnderSparked channel because in a time of nonstop AI channels, we stepped up and used real voice actors to cater to that connection and community that viewers on YouTube crave. We truly believe this demonetization was done in error, all we want is a real human specialist to help us fix the issue. We're tired of constantly receiving only copy and pasted templated responses, constantly neglecting/dismissing our attempts at fixing the false demonetization. We're kindly requesting for a representative from @TeamYouTube to help us fix this demonetization issue with our channel. We don't want to send letters, or sue, or anything! We simply just want to go back to producing content for our community.
English
289
489
2K
119.9K
Fable retweetledi
lily
lily@lilyYtCreator·
. @TeamYouTube @YouTube @YouTubeCreators @nealmohan 🚨 URGENT MANUAL HUMAN REVIEW - 41 DAYS DEMONETIZED Channel: @ililyslife" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@ililyslife (230K subscribers) I have made serious changes to prove my commitment: - Deleted over 200 videos (risking the loss of more than 40 million views) - Left only 5 carefully reviewed videos - Started uploading long-form videos showing clear human effort: hours of raw gameplay, personal scripting, and full manual editing timeline - Reviewed every title, description, tags, and thumbnail Despite all these major actions and submitting a detailed workflow appeal video, I still haven't received any human review after 41 days. This is severely impacting my loyal 230K audience. I'm fully committed to the Youtube Partner Program and I'm willing to improve and make any additional changes required Attached: Strike, editing timeline, current channel (5 videos only), new long-form examples, and proof of 40M+ views lost. Please escalate this for a proper manual human review. Thank you 🙏
lily tweet medialily tweet medialily tweet medialily tweet media
English
3
6
18
831
Fable retweetledi
RPHM
RPHM@RPHManime·
Hey @TeamYouTube My channel was incorrectly flagged for “inauthentic content” on April 27. I tried appealing twice but every time i did my appeal got rejected by the automated system, without any human review. I don't make Ai generated videos, i don't even use templates to mass produce or reupload the same video with minimal changes, i make anime related content with my original stories, all of my videos have: - unique ideas - different & and unique scripts - edited by me. - Visuals and edits I make myself in Photoshop + Canva In the 1:39 video attached, i showed my content creation process. So please, I respectfully request a manual human review of my channel. I’ve spent the last 3 years building this channel and audience through original work, and I would truly appreciate another review. This is my channel: @rphmanime?si=Sd2rCBbd5JD58cX6" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@rphmanime?si=… Case id: 7-5118000041125 & 1-9196000040580 Please YouTube, I only ask for one human review of my content.
English
9
13
20
1.2K
Fable retweetledi
ARAS TV
ARAS TV@ARASTV_YTB·
I followed every instruction from @TeamYouTube support, deleted 100 million views, and spent 90+ days rebuilding my channel—all based on your advice. If a cold AI is going to decide everything anyway, why make me jump through hoops? Stop toying with a 950k channel. I demand a human review! 🛑 #YouTube #CreatorSupport #Monetization
ARAS TV tweet media
English
7
10
17
1.1K
Reece | Clipping Agency
Reece | Clipping Agency@Rhyscryptoo·
final batch of the month. i'm taking 7 people directly into our top-performing campaign of may. $6 cpm. crypto. proven by 100+ existing clippers. zero coaching. zero calls. zero group chat. you get the brief, the creator list, the schedule. reply "clipping platform" by friday 6pm est. i pick saturday morning.
English
31
0
21
1.3K
Fable retweetledi
Raven Reads
Raven Reads@ReadsRaven·
Hey all - this is a last-ditch request to @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators to remonetize my channels. I am asking for a MANUAL, HUMAN review. My family and I are literally facing the loss of our home because bots think I'm inauthentic. So to anyone I have ever provided authentic
English
22
56
73
3.1K
Fable retweetledi
lily
lily@lilyYtCreator·
I’ve proven so many things to show that my content is NOT mass-produced and not inauthentic or templated. I’ve lost so many viewers and so many subscribers due to deleting more than 200 videos. I showed my editing screen and everything to @TeamYouTube. I’m NOT a bot and I don’t upload any inauthentic content, yet the bot still thinks my channel is templated and mass-produced. Im losing thousands of my +230k subscribers EVERYDAY Where’s the fairness @TeamYouTube ?
English
2
2
15
1K
Fable retweetledi
Atom's Whisper
Atom's Whisper@atomswhisperr·
It has been 30 days since my 3D animation channel was demonetized for “Inauthentic Content.”My channel, Atom’s Whisper, has 375K subscribers and over 323M views. I create 3D animated educational Shorts, mostly about interesting scientific experiments. @TeamYoutube @Youtube @YoutubeCreators Every visual in my videos is completely made by me from scratch in Blender. Each animation takes me at least 4–5 days to complete. After that, I edit the videos with sound effects, captions, and licensed music.Despite all this effort, YouTube flagged my channel as “inauthentic” and “mass-produced.” I submitted an appeal. But my appeal was rejected with what looked like a generic response. I requested another review, but the reply looked almost identical again. It honestly feels like my channel may never have received a proper human review. My channel:@atomswhisper" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@atomswhisper I uploaded a long-form video showing my entire workflow and production process on youtube. Everyone supported me there. Thanks! I’ve seen several similar creators get their monetization back, and I’m genuinely happy for them: @TheBioloco @Earthfanboy0 @Meowbananacat @punit_verma67 @NYKentertain @MindlessPixels4. But I believe my channel also deserves a proper human review. I’ve posted about this several times here on X. Each time, @TeamYouTube asks me to contact support via email. But whenever I do, support only tells me that my appeal was reviewed and that I must wait 90 days before reapplying. The hardest part is that they never specifically explained what issue my channel supposedly has that they demonetized it. I feel completely stuck in an endless loop, and mentally this has been extremely exhausting. I’ve spent around 1.5 years building this channel. I truly enjoy creating these animations, but this channel is also my only livelihood. I respectfully request @TeamYouTube to please take proper steps this time and not simply redirect me back to support again. I only want a fair human review of my work. #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #3danimation #youtubepolicy
Atom's Whisper tweet mediaAtom's Whisper tweet mediaAtom's Whisper tweet media
English
12
11
22
813
Fable retweetledi
Real Data 3D
Real Data 3D@realdata3d1·
My channel (Real Data 3D) was demonetized for “inauthentic” content, but I create all animations myself in Blender. I submitted proof, but the appeal video shows 0 views. Please review manually and fix this. 🙏Channel: @RealData3D1" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@RealData3D1 @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators
English
5
6
13
1.2K
Fable retweetledi
Monumental
Monumental@real_Monumental·
My channel was REmonetized today. I know a lot of you are still fighting for your channels and feel left in the dark and hopeless. I get it. I wanted to make this video real quick just explaining some of the steps I took over the last month that may have helped in getting YouTube to finally review my case. I also recommend a couple of simple things that you should do that may help you get your channel back. I'm not promising I can solve everyone's demonetization issues here, but I know how devastating it is to lose your channel and to have no idea what to do to get it back. These are things that were recommended to me by others, and they helped me out, so I'm hoping they can help you too!
English
40
26
108
5.2K
Fable retweetledi
Krispy
Krispy@astrokrispy·
Update… Our 2nd Appeal Was Rejected after 12 days of waiting for a result Despite submitting a detailed video appeal, a written justification and invoking EU DSA law YouTube still could not identify a single specific video or element on KrispyFlights that violated their policy. Hoping that posting here draws the right attention to this situation and @TeamYouTube can restore monetization.
Krispy tweet media
Krispy@astrokrispy

YouTube's AI just killed my channel... YouTube just demonetized my channel KrispyFlights for "inauthentic content" and I'm struggling to make sense of it. Every single video on this channel begins with an original idea, developed by a team of three writers, with a main character even voiced by me. Every visual is deliberately chosen to match that story and that story alone. We've grown to 520,000 subscribers and 800 million views by making content that people genuinely love and now miss (comments below) — with our revenue suspended without a meaningful explanation. I submitted a detailed video appeal demonstrating our full production process. It was rejected with a template response citing generic policy. @TeamYouTube I'm asking a real human to look into this. Not an automated review. We all deserve better than this.

English
25
17
54
3.4K
Fable retweetledi
NoBotsForSupport
NoBotsForSupport@NoBotForSupport·
I’m seeing a clear pattern — so many @YouTube creators are raising the alarm again and again, literally begging for a manual human review on their demonetized channels, monetization bans, or blocked accounts. Years of original content, loyal subscriber bases they built from scratch, countless hours of creativity and passion… all stonewalled by automated flags and endless bot replies with zero real human eyes on their appeals. @YouTube @YouTubeCreators @TeamYouTube — these creators ARE the platform. They grow your audience and your revenue. Prioritize HUMAN support and proper manual reviews NOW. Keep ignoring them and you’re destroying your own credibility with the entire creator community. Our motto stays unbreakable: No Bot For Support — bring back real human support! #FixYouTube #YouTubeCreators #NoBotForSupport #BringBackHumanSupport #CreatorSupport #YouTubeAppeals
English
9
31
86
10.5K
Fable retweetledi
lily
lily@lilyYtCreator·
. @TeamYouTube @YouTube @YouTubeCreators @nealmohan 🚨 URGENT MANUAL HUMAN REVIEW REQUEST - 38 DAYS DEMONETIZED Channel: @ililyslife" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@ililyslife (230K subscribers) After 38 days of demonetization for "Inauthentic Content", I have taken major actions: - Deleted over 200 videos - Left only 5 carefully reviewed videos - Started uploading long-form videos with clear human effort: hours of raw Roblox gameplay recording, personal scripting, and heavy manual editing. Key points: - 100% human-created content with visible effort - Submitted detailed workflow appeal video showing the full process - I'm fully committed to YouTube policies and **I'm willing to improve and make any changes required** This long delay is severely impacting my livelihood and my loyal 230K audience. Attached: Strike, editing timeline, current channel (only 5 videos), new long-form examples, raw gameplay clips, and workflow proof. Please escalate immediately to Creator Support for a proper manual human review. Thank you 🙏
lily tweet medialily tweet medialily tweet medialily tweet media
English
8
7
29
1.7K
Fable retweetledi
Youri Leerkotte
Youri Leerkotte@Archmeton·
So for the past 4 weeks I've been contacting YT support about a channel using an AI clone of my voice, and more of my brand, and I keep getting endless emails circling to nothing. Literally been 30 emails later and still just AI responses. We've over a million subs @YouTube. and this is how you treat us? Crazy ignorant.
English
6
2
12
1.7K
Fable retweetledi
RAY DOCS
RAY DOCS@RayDocsProd·
(please help me get visibility by reposting and mentioning @TeamYouTube) 🚨My YouTube channel “Ray Docs” was demonetized for “inauthentic content” despite the fact that everything I create is 100% original. This channel was my dream project: combining my lifelong passion for WWE with content creation. I create AI-assisted 3D WWE animation videos while pushing detail and quality as far as possible. I spend hours creating the scenes, refining them, and then editing every video myself with real effort and care behind each upload. For the past month, I’ve been trapped in a loop of automated responses, generic explanations, and rejected appeals without ever being told what specific content is supposedly violating the rules. Meanwhile: 👉My views collapsed 👉My motivation disappeared 👉Almost $4,000 of my earnings remain frozen 👉And my mental health has genuinely suffered I completely understand YouTube fighting spam and mass-produced AI content. But genuine creators are getting caught in the crossfire. I’m not asking for special treatment. I’m simply asking for: - a real human review - transparency - and a clear explanation of what needs to be fixed Please @TeamYouTube don’t let automated systems destroy real creative projects built with passion, creativity, and hard work.
RAY DOCS tweet mediaRAY DOCS tweet mediaRAY DOCS tweet media
RAY DOCS@RayDocsProd

🚨@TeamYouTube we just want transparency, a fair treatment and human revision. We just want to provide value to the platform Please @TeamYouTube my channel got hit with the inauthentic content demonetization. You have all the info under this case 1-4564000040520. Take a look

English
20
21
59
2.8K
RedPillAries
RedPillAries@RedPillAries·
Need more clippers Comment 💊 if you want to join the team 🙋‍♂️
English
14
6
34
2.1K
Fable retweetledi
sxrn
sxrn@basarabia490348·
@TeamYouTube I don’t even know what to say anymore. First, at 3 AM, I received an official YouTube Support email saying my YPP appeal was successful and that my channel could monetize again. I was so excited thinking I finally got my channel back. The next day, I opened chat support only to ask why monetization still wasn’t showing in YouTube Studio. Then, during that exact chat conversation, I received a second official YouTube Support email saying the opposite — that my appeal was unsuccessful and I have to wait 90 days. Is this right, YouTube? Do you think this is fair to creators? How can you send me a wrong approval email and then just say I’m actually not eligible? I couldn’t sleep all night because I thought my channel was back. I will post the screenshots of both emails and the chat conversation. I’m only asking for a clear final answer and a proper human review from a real monetization specialist. Email case ID: 6-9049000040882 Chat case ID: 2-3108000040481
sxrn tweet mediasxrn tweet media
English
13
13
29
11.4K