Aditya Goenka

498 posts

Aditya Goenka

Aditya Goenka

@FoxbatFury

Katılım Haziran 2013
557 Takip Edilen84 Takipçiler
West Bengal Diary
West Bengal Diary@WestBengalDiary·
🚃 NUISANCE OR BLESSING? The Case For and Against Reviving Kolkata's Trams — And Why the Answer Matters More Than Ever 👇 Kolkata has a road space problem that most people do not fully grasp. Only 6% of the city's land area is road. The ideal for a well-planned city is 15-30%. Mumbai manages 18%. Delhi 10%. Kolkata — a city of 14 million people — has 6%. The result: 2,448 vehicles per kilometre of road. For comparison, Delhi has approximately 400. Into this context, the tram debate is not really about heritage or nostalgia. It is about mathematics. And the mathematics, examined carefully, makes a surprising argument. THE CASE AGAINST The government's position is not irrational. Trams are fixed-path vehicles on a city where every metre of road is already contested. They share carriageways with cars, auto-rickshaws, motorcycles, and cycle rickshaws. When a vehicle parks on a tram track — and vehicles do — the entire route stops. When a two-wheeler skids on a rail — and they do — there is an accident. The current fleet is outdated. Operations lose money. Routes cannot adapt around new flyovers or metro construction sites. The infrastructure requires sustained investment that a state with limited fiscal capacity struggles to prioritise. Critics argue that modern electric buses and an expanding metro network deliver similar environmental benefits without the inflexibility of fixed tracks on narrow roads. These are real concerns. They deserve honest acknowledgement. THE CASE FOR Studies of former tram routes in Kolkata show something that contradicts the official narrative: removing the trams did not ease congestion. Private vehicles simply filled the space. Traffic levels on former tram corridors stayed the same or worsened after the tracks were removed. This is not surprising. It is what happened in London, Sydney, and every other city that removed its trams in the 20th century — and then spent billions rebuilding them in the 21st. One tram carries more people than dozens of cars. In a city with only 6% road space, the argument for high-capacity surface transit is stronger — not weaker — than in cities with more room. The constraint is precisely the reason to move more people per square metre, not fewer. Kolkata's own Comprehensive Air Quality Action Plan — mandated under the National Clean Air Programme — explicitly calls for tram modernisation and network development. The city has committed to C40 Green Mobility targets. Removing the only zero-emission surface transit system in India while committing to clean air targets is a direct contradiction. Trams produce zero tailpipe emissions. No toxic battery waste. No noise. A modern low-floor AC tram running on renewable electricity is the cleanest form of urban surface transport that exists. THE VERDICT The question is not trams versus no trams. It is old trams on shared roads with no enforcement versus modern trams on dedicated lanes with signal priority and strict no-parking enforcement. The first version is genuinely a nuisance. The second is what Melbourne, Lyon, Dublin, and Edinburgh have built — and it works in every city that has tried it. Kolkata's tram network has shrunk from 70 kilometres and dozens of routes at its peak to approximately 8-25 kilometres on 2-3 routes today. Asia's first electric tramway — 1902, first in the continent — is running on three routes. The Calcutta Tram Users Association, citizen movements, and the Calcutta High Court have all pushed back against the phase-out. The momentum for revival exists. What has been missing is a government willing to make the policy decisions that turn old infrastructure into modern transit. West Bengal has a new government. The tram question is now on its desk. Half-measures — old fleet, shared roads, no enforcement — would confirm every critic's worst fears. Smart revival — new low-floor AC trams, dedicated lanes, integrated ticketing with the metro — could make Kolkata the only Indian city with a functioning 21st-century tramway. Asia gave the world its first electric tram in 1902. In Kolkata. It would be fitting if Asia showed the world how to revive one too. #KolkataTrams #NuisanceOrBlessing #SaveTheTram #BengalRising #NewGovernment #GreenMobility #HeritageCulture #AsiaFirstElectricTram
West Bengal Diary tweet media
West Bengal Diary@WestBengalDiary

🚃 HERITAGE & CULTURE | KOLKATA In 1873, Kolkata gave Asia its first tram. 152 years later, the city is fighting to keep its last one alive. This may be the most bittersweet transport story in Bengal’s history. 🧵👇 🕰️ THE BIRTH OF AN ICON It began on a single track. 3.9 kilometres. Horse-drawn. Sealdah to Armenian Ghat. The year was 1873 — two years before Alexander Graham Bell invented the telephone. On 24 February 1873, the first tram in Asia began running in Calcutta. The service initially lasted only about a month and was suspended due to lack of demand. But the dream was too powerful to abandon. The Calcutta Tramways Company was formally constituted in 1880 — laying metre-gauge tracks, reintroducing horse trams, and even briefly experimenting with steam-powered trams in the early 1880s. Then came the moment that changed everything. In 1900 electrification began, and on 27 March 1902, the first electric tramcar ran from Esplanade to Kidderpore. This made Kolkata the first city in all of Asia to operate electric tramways. -Not Tokyo. -Not Shanghai. -Not Singapore. Kolkata 🩷 কলকাতার ট্রাম — এশিয়ার প্রথম বৈদ্যুতিক পথচলা। Kolkata’s tram — Asia’s first electric journey. Today, Kolkata’s tram system remains one of the oldest continuously operating tram networks in the world. 🌟 THE GOLDEN AGE By the mid-20th century, the Calcutta tram was not just a vehicle. It was the circulatory system of an entire city. By the 1960s — the undisputed golden age — the network operated around 37 routes across Kolkata and Howrah. The system had: ▸ Around 67 kilometres of track ▸ A fleet of roughly 450 tramcars ▸ Hundreds of thousands of passengers every day The tram was the working man’s chariot. The student’s commute. The mill worker’s lifeline. With fares so low that workers and students could easily afford them, the tram carried Bengali society across class lines — the professor and the fish seller, the lawyer and the labourer, sharing the same wooden bench, watching the same city roll by at 15 km/h. Satyajit Ray filmed it. Ritwik Ghatak used it as metaphor. Mrinal Sen framed it against the Howrah Bridge. The tram wasn’t just transportation — it was Kolkata’s personality on rails. এই ট্রামে শুধু মানুষ নয়, বাংলার ইতিহাস চলত। These trams carried not just people — but Bengal’s history. 📉 THE LONG DECLINE The decline began with a mindset — not a malfunction. In the 1970s, global thinking declared trams obsolete. Buses were modern. Cars were progress. The tram — slow, fixed-track, sharing the road — was suddenly seen as the villain of congestion. Cities across India dismantled their systems. Mumbai removed its trams in 1964. Delhi closed its network soon after. Chennai followed. Kolkata kept going. But barely. On 8 November 1976, the Calcutta Tramways Company was nationalised. Over the following decades: -Routes closed. -Depots shut down. -Tracks were paved over. -The fleet steadily shrank. By the 1990s, serious plans were proposed to close the network entirely. What helped revive global interest in Kolkata’s trams was something unexpected. In 1994, Melbourne tram conductor Roberto D’Andrea visited Kolkata, fell in love with its trams and workers, and helped spark an international cultural exchange. The Tramjatra Festival was born — linking tram workers and artists from Melbourne and Kolkata, turning the tram into a cultural symbol worth preserving. An Australian helped ignite a global movement to protect Kolkata’s trams. Think about that. ⚖️ THE BATTLE FOR SURVIVAL: 2024–2025 Fast forward to 2024. The West Bengal government announced plans to close most tram services, retaining only a small heritage route between Maidan and Esplanade. The reason given: traffic congestion. Kolkata erupted. Filmmaker Goutam Ghose said what many were thinking: “The Howrah Bridge, trams and yellow taxis are Kolkata’s icons. Globally trams are popular — we should modernise them, not destroy them.” Citizens organised protests. The Calcutta Tram Users Association (@CTUA) — formed in 2016 — challenged the closure. The Calcutta High Court intervened, seeking detailed reports before any permanent removal of tram infrastructure. The debate is ongoing. But one thing became clear. বাংলার মানুষ তার ট্রামকে ছাড়েনি। Bengal’s people have not abandoned their tram. 🌍 WHAT THE WORLD KNOWS THAT KOLKATA FORGOT Around the world, the story of trams went in the opposite direction. Today: ▸ 450+ cities operate tram systems ▸ Dozens of cities have rebuilt tram networks they once removed ▸ Cities denser than Kolkata — Paris, Melbourne, Hong Kong, Barcelona, Toronto — rely heavily on trams Why? Because trams are: ▸ Zero direct emissions ▸ Quiet and energy efficient ▸ Able to replace 50–70 cars on a road The argument that trams cause congestion is the same argument London made when it removed its trams in the 1950s. Today London has spent billions rebuilding modern tram lines. Sometimes cities realise too late what they lost. 🌟 THE POSITIVE NOTE Kolkata’s trams are more than transportation. During moments of social tension in the city’s history, the steady movement of trams through mixed neighbourhoods created everyday contact between communities. The tram became community on rails. The Smaranika Tram Museum at Esplanade preserves this history — displaying original tram parts, tickets and mechanical components from a system that once defined the city. 152 years ago, a horse pulled a wooden carriage along 3.9 kilometres of track in Calcutta. Asia had never seen anything like it. Today, a citizens’ movement, heritage activists and the stubborn pride of Kolkata are keeping that story alive. The tram is slow. That is precisely the point. In a city that moves too fast and remembers too little — the tram forces you to look out the window. To see the city. To feel it. কলকাতার ট্রাম শুধু একটা যান নয়। এটা আমাদের আত্মা। 🚃❤️ Kolkata’s tram is not just a vehicle. It is our soul.🚃❤️ @WBGOVT @MamataOfficial @kmc_kolkata @Kolkata @KolkataTCOE @nkda_mar @new_townkolkata @KolkataTCOE @KolkataPlus @_CTUA_ @projectmcra

English
12
8
43
2K
Aditya Goenka retweetledi
Crypto Jargon
Crypto Jargon@Crypto_Jargon·
Interview is Live! We discussed the following: - WazirX issue - How crypto whales operate the market - Indian crypto users and their pain points - My strategy for trading Crypto Assets - Memecoins - Celebrity/Influencer Rugpulls - Hamster effect on Indian crypto space and much more..... Watch it here youtube.com/watch?v=iVj66H…
YouTube video
YouTube
Crypto Jargon@Crypto_Jargon

Had a informative podcast at Zee news today, don't miss it! Coming soon

English
127
239
315
20K
Aditya Goenka
Aditya Goenka@FoxbatFury·
@Paytm You are redeeming the FD created in the PayTM payments bank account but the UPI facility is stopped for this account, also the Bank Transfer function on the PayTM app is not working! Now, the FD is broken, still I am unable to transfer the funds to my other bank account
English
3
0
0
74
Aditya Goenka retweetledi
Crypto Point Hindi 🇮🇳💎💫
If WazirX issue is not resolved on time and with proper communication, can lead to devastating consequences for Indian Crypto Ecosystem. Exchange should come forward with clear and user friendly solution. No Hate, Community Needs Solution! #WazirX
English
49
161
400
8.6K
Victorforce
Victorforce@Victorforce2·
When Pakis helplessly watched Indian Airforce Mig-25 "Garuda" buzz their Airspace for strategic reconnaissance 25 years ago.
English
41
501
2K
0
Aditya Singh
Aditya Singh@cryptoady·
Any of you getting COVID injection ?
English
46
4
73
0
Aditya Goenka
Aditya Goenka@FoxbatFury·
How to treat the interest on lending for the purpose of filing IT Return in India? Will this come under IFoS or be treated as Capital Gain when we liquidate our holding? #AskSumitAboutCrypto
English
0
0
1
0
Aditya Goenka retweetledi
Ankit Vanigota
Ankit Vanigota@anky17cool·
@AmazonHelp The product was in stock for sale, but there is no product to provide for replacement for the same, here is an update video for the same @amazonIN @OnePlus_IN Check the availability notification and date and time of the same it is of today itself
English
3
11
1
0
Aditya Goenka retweetledi
Ankit Vanigota
Ankit Vanigota@anky17cool·
@OnePlus_IN @amazonIN Thank you for sending in a second hand bud for the price of a brand new one, Can't express the gratitude I have for this, Thank you for having such unbelievable service #OnePlusBuds
Ankit Vanigota tweet mediaAnkit Vanigota tweet media
English
2
14
4
0
Arun Bothra 🇮🇳
Arun Bothra 🇮🇳@arunbothra·
I would have topped the UPSC If I had a teacher like him 😅
English
846
3.7K
19.8K
0
Aditya Goenka retweetledi
World of Engineering
World of Engineering@engineers_feed·
2020 ★ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ Very bad, wouldn’t recommend
English
173
3.7K
28.8K
0