@Joeinblack We eschew those terms and it’s something like conversion class (a bit awkward but everyone has figured out what it means)
English
Matthew Roth
26.9K posts
Matthew Roth
@MatthewJRoth
Ma vie n’est qu’un instant, une heure passagère… (sainte Thérèse de Lisieux)
เข้าร่วม Aralık 2012
763 กำลังติดตาม1.2K ผู้ติดตาม
Every time an announcement is made inviting people to “join OCIA” instead of “Classes to become Catholic” or “Catholic class”, an angel loses their wings.
English
Young men, it is completely normal and natural to not know what that pointy leafy green stuff growing in your neighbor’s front yard is, what matters is that you do not, under any circumstances, touch it
Tanner Cartwright 🇺🇸🇬🇧🏴@TanneriteCortez
Young men, it is completely normal and natural to want a wife who has never slept with other men. Don’t let them convince you it isn’t.
English
@CatholicSmark @OscarRodval Idk if it’s even necessary to go down that route
The left liberal is always going to destroy things if that’s necessary with no reservations; that doesn’t mean that they all will all the time
English
@MatthewJRoth @OscarRodval I think the issue is not so much "left liberals" so much as it is insecure people starving for a legacy. Even most left liberals wanted to leave this alone. Yet most left liberals weren't a failed pope desperate for recognition and loathing of his predecessors admiration.
English
I don't know Leo's personal thoughts on the TLM, but I think irrespective of his beliefs, the Church is going to incrementally (and the unfortunate emphasis on INCREMENTALLY) return Summorum Pontificum, just call it something else so Francis' legacy isn't entirely destroyed.
English
@CatholicSmark @OscarRodval What BXVI intended and could not get. Francis was not so compelled personally and so he overturned his predecessor. The problem of dealing with left liberals. x.com/matthewjroth/s…
Matthew Roth@MatthewJRoth
@M_P_Hazell @CatholicSmark I would like to see a more definitive solution BXVI felt constrained by convention. The Curia refused to work on an apostolic constitution so he went with SP which was much easier to change in one day versus an AC (even if amendable etc.)
English
@OscarRodval Certainly didn't. And I agree with others (think it was @MatthewJRoth) who said we need something more definitive in the long run beyond just a motu proprio to do a definitive settlement.
But I think the overall outline will eventually be that.
English
@ConstantCate @ChivalryGuild And who mostly don’t have pensions (a few states & blue urban districts aside)
English
@ChivalryGuild Someone who started teaching 35 years ago with just a BA and someone starting now who has to get a master's degree are not in the same boat.
English
The retired teacher behind the counter at our local health food store told me his pension clears $5K/month after taxes. Don't know why he felt it necessary to share that info, but public school teachers are doing better than we've been led to believe.
captive dreamer@captive_dreamer
I think teachers should be paid less, actually
English
@M_P_Hazell @CatholicSmark I would like to see a more definitive solution
BXVI felt constrained by convention. The Curia refused to work on an apostolic constitution so he went with SP which was much easier to change in one day versus an AC (even if amendable etc.)
English
@CatholicSmark One thing seems certain, though: when the moment arrives, some people are going to have a *really* hard time climbing out of their deep ideological trenches:
English
@romemyhome2525 @CatholicSat Idk what the original point is but they’re all Filipino guest workers
English
Interesting that when Pope Leo XIV greeted pilgrims from Saudi Arabia, they were mentioned with the English-speaking pilgrims, and not with the Arabic speakers. We all know why.
Catholic Sat@CatholicSat
Continuing his catechetical series on Vatican II, Pope Leo XIV reflecting on the Dogmatic Constitution Lumen gentium, and the divinely instituted hierarchical nature of the Church, says: “In our ongoing catechesis on the Second Vatican Council, today we reflect on the teachings of the Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium concerning the hierarchical structure of the Church. In this regard, it is helpful to bear in mind that the Church is not something we invented, but is a divine institution established by Jesus himself. Christ appointed the apostles, placing Peter at their head, and sent them out to continue his salvific mission until his return in glory. To perpetuate this same mission, ministers were invested with sacred power to be the successors of the Apostles as Bishops, in whose ministry priests and deacons likewise participate through the Sacrament of Holy Orders. Sharing in the ministry of Jesus, the Good Shepherd, they are consecrated to serve the faithful, build up the Church and ensure the fruitful transmission of the faith. Let us therefore ask the Lord to continue to bless his Church with shepherds after His own heart.”
English
@CatholicSmark Already the tone shift and occasional remarks that are an obvious reflection on Francis’s vices and the tolerance for bad, rude, or criminal behavior and how maybe this is bad have been a lot
I don’t need a cadaver synod exactly
English
Leo clearly wants an exit ramp. The Bishops don't want to deal with this issue, so I think any attempt to punt to the bishops will fail in the medium (to say nothing of long) term. But we can't just say The Vicar of Christ made a mistake and did something bad. (can but won't)
English
Pick one
This reform is fine, and it’s not about technical details (which would belong to parliament and can be changed by law once the constitution changes) but about Meloni then
English
And actually I may have made too good of a point here; France largely eliminated instruction cases because of corruption. Being able to hold procurators accountable to the executive & therefore the legislature is good.
English
I’m discovering that Italy does not and will continue to not have a division between procurators and judges
That is extraordinary, and it’s not as if Italy has always been this way or has been without previous opportunities for reform: they’ve reformed criminal procedure!
English
@Jahaza True but there definitely is a little bit of people need to get their hands dirty & put in a little more effort and stop podcasting etc
Not to defend to the death professional Catholics & diocesan staff. There’s a lot wrong there too.
English
@CatholicSmark @BigEasyConserv @emzanotti Like what happened with the Dominicaines du Saint-Esprit was made worse bc of TC
Can this go away?
English
@CatholicSmark @BigEasyConserv @emzanotti Yeah
And the French have been all over the place. The CEF hates trads & the TLM. Several major bishops do. They’ve got all sorts of goofiness thanks to TC, persecuting trads, and trying to fix real problems made worse for Rom by using the TLM
English
Yep. Hopefully I’m not just desperate for good news that it sounds good…but this pope picks his words so carefully, it’s hard to believe there’s some other meaning.
Damian Thompson@holysmoke
This could be big news. Hard to read this as anything other than papal support for greater freedom for celebration of the TLM, though it’s frustratingly short on details.
English
@JoshBobBill1 @duncandee I think that you’re obviously low IQ
English
@MatthewJRoth @duncandee Do you think the family was waiting to hear of the fate of their child from a public statement from the CEO or were they informed earlier in a private communication in the language of their choice.
English
24 hours after this tragedy, Mike Rousseau is focused on the welfare of the crew and customers impacted and their families.
The federal transport minister, meanwhile, is fixated on the Official Languages Act.
Montreal Gazette@mtlgazette
“No, Air Canada knows better." Federal Transport Minister Steven MacKinnon said it wasn’t acceptable for Air Canada CEO Michael Rousseau to release a video statement, where he expressed his condolences to those affected by the crash, entirely in English. "They have a responsibility to communicate with the public and their stakeholders in both official languages,” MacKinnon told reporters in Ottawa. Read the latest: montrealgazette.com/news/local-new…
English
@BubbaZanetti9 @HashtagGriswold Which sucks
Also the whiny tweets about new policies get into my feed and I also would prefer not to see them
English
The charitable explanation here is this guy lacks English proficiency to realize his screenshots don’t back up his characterization. Either that, or he’s unintelligent (or thinks his followers are unintelligent).
Either way, I’m okay with tweets like this not being on my feed!
𝐀𝐍𝐓𝐔𝐍𝐄𝐒@Antunes1
Nikita Bier says Creator Payouts will now be affected by the user’s location. But told me personally I wouldn’t get paid at all: “We won’t send you money overseas.” Why is a regular user being targeted like this? I just think this change raises many issues: - What about US citizens living abroad? (many are full time X creators) - What about legitimate international creators? - Users from countries with little user base? (Vatican, 800 people; Andorra, 80k, etc.) - International full time X creators? Why should an account like mine not be paid at all while delivering over 100M impressions a month? Because the Head of Product doesn’t like me? I think @elonmusk should look into this. There are smarter ways to deal with ‘foreign interference’ from 3rd world countries. I was suspended within minutes of respectfully commenting about Nikita, then unbanned by Elon Musk himself. Hope it doesn’t happen again. Just my opinion, respectfully.
English
@JoshBobBill1 @duncandee THE FAMILY IS FRANCOPHONE
They’re not pilots
This is not a gotcha
English
@duncandee He’s going to be pissed when he learns that English is the official language of commercial pilots everywhere
English
Never, in the history of Catholicism, have there not been a myriad of subcultures within the Church, even when most Catholics all used the Tridentine form. Even if everyone used the NOM, there would still be distinct subcultures. This was never considered…
T.J. | Catholic Firebrand@realtjhaines
I’ve said this to death already but I have nothing against the TLM and I personally don’t agree with restrictions on it. My concern is with what many have done with the TLM (a subculture). While I disagreed with Pope Francis restricting it, I didn’t disagree with his reasons. In the end, it’s about unity in the church and unity among our people. That principal is core and central to Catholicism, since 33AD, it isn’t trivial. If what we today call the extraordinary form (TLM) ever became the ordinary form and people did with the Novus Ordo what they are doing with the TLM, I would be saying the exact same thing. It’s not about a Liturgy for me it’s about unity in the Church
English
@UrbanCourtyard @mbolotnikova I am just discovering that you spoke here? I know the oratory community pretty well!! This is very cool
English
I love St. Louis!!! My kids are obsessed with the City Museum there. When I spoke at a Fox Park event in September, I was amazed by all the young families who were sooo interested in family-friendly urbanism. It was endearing and motivating.
I didn’t see your STL compositions but will check them out later :)
English
how to add population to St. Louis fast
Carina 🇺🇸🇨🇱 — Urban Designer & Ghostwriter@anurbancreative
Most people can't visualize their cities differently because they lack the tools. Courtyard Composer changes that. I've been using it all week. And I love how @UrbanCourtyard has been leading this conversation on Courtyard Urbanism, family-friendly cities, and New Aesthetics for American cities. @treasury_space built a tool that takes five minutes to learn—you prompt what you want to see, iterate on the design, and suddenly you're rendering courtyards in any city context. Then you share it and start conversations about what's possible. The tool itself isn't revolutionary. Rendering tech exists. What matters is who gets to use it. Urban design used to require: • Hiring an architect • Waiting weeks for renderings • And hoping stakeholders could interpret 2D plans Now anyone interested in how cities work can sketch ideas and see them in 3D instantly. • An urban design student can test theories without expensive software • A developer can explore options before committing to architectural fees • A neighborhood advocate can show their city council what a courtyard could do for their street. The shift isn't about better technology. Design expertise no longer gatekeeps the conversation about what cities could become. You don't need credentials to imagine better public spaces. You just need to care about where you live and a tool that translates ideas into something everyone can see and discuss. Every visualization becomes a conversation starter. Every render is a proposal for what our streets could be. Start HERE: composer.courtyardurbanist.com The hardest part? Deciding which city to visualize first. Try it—prompt a courtyard in your city and share what you create. I'd like to see what you come up with. --- 📌 Join the movement at courtyardurbanist.com
English
@2aQueer @legalstyleblog OTOH 10/11 in Mass use -borough officially but Mass DOT uses -boro (& it’s often Foxboro)
English
@legalstyleblog The US Board on Geographic names is also responsible for every US place ending in 'burgh' changed to 'burg', except Pittsburgh, PA which changed it back. Also any place ending in 'borough' being changed to 'boro'. Hence Marlboro and not Marlborough.
English
Because this is the way they spelt things in 1683—inconsistently
Benjamin Lewis@tc1415
Why doesn't Queens (in NY) have a possessive apostrophe?
English
@glbaumann @bobbyfijan Yeah
And I sometimes just sit there. Like can’t focus to read. Don’t want to listen to music. Movies? Meh.
It’s actually quite nice being able to sit in silence.
English
I’d pay more for window seats bc my superpower is sleeping on planes
I fly ALL the time and the only way I stay sane is by falling asleep before plane gets to cruising altitude
I always take the window. I never recline. I pull my hat over my eyes, put on music, and go to sleep
Patrick Ruffini@PatrickRuffini
The latest @davidshor data has prompted an unapologetic defense from me of the window seat, a lifelong preference it turns out is lower-class coded.
English